This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you. Please read the full disclosure here. 

 

 

If you sell handmade, you’re likely aware of Etsy. But a lot of people are wondering where they can sell their handmade items online, aside from Etsy.

 

Perhaps because Etsy changed their algorithm so traffic and sales aren’t what they used to be, or maybe they feel their category is too saturated. Whatever the reason, this article shares several suggestions for additional ways to sell handmade online.

 

30+ ETSY ALTERNATIVES

Here’s a list of over 30 online marketplaces you can use to sell your handmade products.

 

BASED ON LOCATION

The country listed next to each marketplace is where the majority of their traffic comes from, and in most cases, also where the website is based. Some allow users outside the country to join while others do not.

1. AMAZON HANDMADE (US)

2. ARTFIRE (US)

3. ZIBBET (US)

4. AFTCRA (US)

5. HANDMADE ARTISTS (US)

6. INDIECART (US)

7. ICRAFTGIFTS (CANADA)

8. FOLKSY (UK)

9. MISI (UK)

10. MADEIT (AUSTRALIA)

11. FELT (NEW ZEALAND)

 

BASED ON TARGET MARKET

You can also try different online marketplaces based on the type of customer they attract (not just by location).

12. CARGOH – is a curated marketplace so the products featured are a little more selective and may attract a different type of shopper who’s looking for higher-end products and doesn’t want to search through thousands of jewelry listings to find the right pair of earrings.

13. BONANZA – is sort of a mix of Etsy, Ebay and Amazon so it attracts a customer who’s interested in more than just handmade. They share customer insights, unlike Etsy, so it may be easier for you to build your business through repeat customers.

14. UNCOMMON GOODS – is not like Etsy where anyone can sign up and start listing handmade goods but rather a site you can submit your products to, they’ll review them and if they’re a fit, they’ll carry them in their online marketplace. They attract a target market looking for really unique and obviously, “uncommon” products.

15. REBELS MARKET – this is a marketplace to list edgy alternative designs. Think: goth, steampunk, heavy metal, etc. If those are words you’d use to describe your products, consider listing them on this marketplace.

 

BASED ON CATEGORY

There are also a few options for selling a specific type of product.

 

KNITTING/CROCHET

16. RAVELRY – if you create knitting or crochet patterns, spin or dye yarn for sale, you can list it on this site

 

ART

These websites (there are many more for artists but these are my top picks) allow artists and/or photographers to upload their work and sell it as prints or apply it to a variety of products (such as mugs, t-shirts, phone cases, etc.)

17. CAFEPRESS

18. SOCIETY6

19. ZAZZLE

20. REDBUBBLE

21. DEVIANT ART

22. 99DESIGNS (if you’re a graphic designer and are interested in creating custom designs for businesses)

23. SPOONFLOWER

 

SELLING WHOLESALE ONLINE

Most people think of brick and mortar stores when they think of selling their products wholesale. But there are plenty of online stores that need products to stock their pages with. The following platforms may help you reach those retailers online.

24. AMAZON BUSINESS (most categories of products)

25. STOCKABL (most categories of products)

26. ETSY WHOLESALE (most categories of products) Shut down

27. INDIEME (most categories of products)

28. BRANDBOOM

29. JOOR (fashion)

30. LE NEW BLACK (fashion)

31. MOUTH (food)

32. RANGEME (this business works with major retailers so your product must be ready to sell wholesale in large quantities)

33. WHOLESALE IN A BOX (most categories of products)

 

MARKETPLACE & WEBSITE MIX

If you’re not quite ready to build a website of your own but want to be a bit more independent and have more control than Etsy allows, these are a couple of good options:

34. INDIEMADE – made for artists but has less of a community than an online marketplace like Etsy has.

35. STORENVY – this one is both a website and an online marketplace in one. It allows you to create your own website but also shows your listings in Storenvy’s marketplace.

 

SUBSCRIPTION BOX

I like the idea of handmade businesses creating subscription boxes because it allows you to sell multiple items with one sale AND you generate consistent revenue from month to month.

 

If you’re not familiar with subscription boxes, basically, you would create a package of products that follow a theme; they may be all your products, you may work with other vendors to fill a box, or you may purchase items at wholesale prices to include in your box.

 

Customers would subscribe to receiving your package each month, which may simply be a refill, or it may be new products for them to try.

 

For example, let’s say I sell bath and body products. I may create a “Sustainable Shower Subscription Box” with my vegan shampoo, vegan conditioner, vegan shower gel, and vegan shaving cream. When a customer signs up for that subscription box, they’re signing up to receive it each month and will be charged a monthly fee for it; consistent and reliable income without you having to constantly market to that customer or remind them to re-purchase!

 

Here’s a good guide for getting started: How to Start a Subscription Box Guide

 

36. CRATEJOY – a website for buying and listing subscription boxes. Consumers can find hundreds of subscription boxes to subscribe to under a variety of categories.

 

 

HOW TO SELL CRAFTS LOCALLY ONLINE

If you want to sell your handmade products online but you don’t want to ship your items (i.e. you’d prefer to meet up with people in your city for an exchange), or you want to target consumers who live closer to you (e.g. in your state/province), consider the following options.

 

37. ECWID

Ecwid is a platform that allows you to create listings and then sync those listings with a Facebook page, Instagram account, website, marketplace, or even accept payments in-person.

 

Let’s say you have a Facebook Page set up, which you use to market your products but you don’t have a way to sell those products on Facebook.

 

You would:

  • Set up an Ecwid account, (choose the Venture or Business plan)
  • Add your products to your account
  • Go to Ecwid Control Panel → All sales channels → Sell on Facebook and click “Connect Facebook page”
  • Select the Facebook page where you want to add your products and click “Save”

 

Your products are now available for people to shop and buy, right on your Facebook page. You’ll see a tab on the left side of your Facebook page titled “Facebook Shop”

 

 

38. BUILD A WEBSITE

Do you need your own website to sell handmade? No; especially not in the beginning. But you should have a website if you’re serious about building a successful business.

 

As a consumer, I can only gather so much information from a business’s Etsy shop and if I’m going to become a loyal customer (e.g. purchase regularly, visit their site regularly, take a chance on higher-priced goods, etc.), I want to be able to visit a dedicated website to sign up for their newsletter, add to my bookmarks, learn more about the business, etc.

 

Websites have become easier to build, without expensive developers, through tools like:

  • Shopify
  • Wix
  • Weebly
  • Squarespace

 

However, it takes months, sometimes even years, to begin seeing decent organic traffic, so it’s a good idea to get your website up and running sooner than later; even if you don’t plan to drive traffic to it yet.

 

Organic traffic is website traffic that comes from visitors who discover your website when searching phrases on search engines like Google, as opposed to traffic that visits your website by clicking on your paid ad or social media post.

 

It requires work to gain organic traffic because you must write blog articles, create listings and have a site that’s attractive to Google in many different ways (e.g. loads quickly, is linked to from other sites, etc.). However, an SEO friendly blog post or product listing is posted to your site once and can continue to attract traffic over time. Unlike traffic from a platform like Facebook or a paid ad where you must continue to post or pay to see traffic to your site.

 

You can focus website content on keywords you want your website to rank for. For example, if I have a jewelry business and I want to sell my pieces online, but to people who live within my city or province, I can focus on using my city and province’s names in my content (e.g. “Earrings handmade in Alberta”)/

 

You’re also able to build your brand and collect newsletter subscribers through your website, which is harder to do on Etsy.

 

So my suggestion is to get a website up as soon as you’re comfortable doing so. You don’t have to worry about loads of traffic coming in and having too many orders to handle as soon as you hit publish. You can perfect it over the first several weeks, while it’s live, without anyone (besides Google) actually seeing it. You may see the odd visit here and there but not much until you start sharing links to your website and Google starts showing it in top search results (which can take months).

 

39. FACEBOOK MARKETPLACE

People list everything from furniture to houses on Facebook Marketplace. It doesn’t necessarily help a business with their branding (because there’s such a hodge-podge of products and services listed), but it may work for a business starting out that wants to test the local market.

 

40. KIJIJI – a classified site that attracts all types of sellers selling all types of items. The purpose is to buy and sell locally so depending on what you sell, it may be an option when starting out.

 

41. CRAIGSLIST – similar to Kijiji

 

For more places to sell your crafts locally, check out: WHERE TO SELL HANDMADE LOCALLY

 

 

WHAT IS THE BEST WEBSITE TO SELL HANDMADE ITEMS?

That depends on which factor determines “best”.

 

In my opinion, traffic is the most important factor. The reason people use an online marketplace instead of simply starting their own website is because the marketplace attracts more traffic.

 

If a marketplace brings traffic to you, it’s up to you to convert that traffic into your paying customers and price products to cover the fees that marketplace is charging you. So although cost is important, your business can increase prices to cover the higher costs one marketplace may charge.

 

Of the more well-known handmade marketplaces, these 5 rank in the following order:

>> Amazon is ranked in the top 20 out of websites in the entire world and within the top 5 in the US. It would be hard for any other online marketplace to compete with that. However, the traffic Amazon receives, which helps them rank so high, isn’t all going to their “handmade” section.

>> Etsy comes in second place for traffic, ranking within the top 150 website globally and within the top 50 in the US.

>> Artfire comes next but Etsy has a big lead on them, then Zibbet, then Folksy.

 

 

 

WHERE TO SELL CRAFTS ONLINE FOR FREE

This is a question I see come up a lot. When it comes to selling your products online for free, your options are limited.

 

Classified sites are typically free to post and sell because transactions happen off the platform. Examples of classified sites are:

  • Facebook Marketplace
  • Kijiji
  • Craigslist

 

These wouldn’t be my top choices for handmade businesses selling online because they tend to be platforms people use to sell their unwanted items and where buyers go to find a good deal. Those are two things we don’t want to be associated with your handmade products: “unwanted” and “good deal”.

 

That being said, if your craft business is in the startup phase and you’re short on cash, you can test these types of platforms out. Just be sure to keep your listings on-brand. Meaning, if you want people to see your handmade products as valuable items, post professional-looking photos, have well-written descriptions, respond to messages in a timely manner, etc.

 

Technically, you can use a business social media account to “list” your products and encourage people to direct message you to purchase an item. This method can be hard to track sales and isn’t the most streamlined experience for the customer. If you plan to accept payments online, you’ll need a PayPal account (or another payment account) to accept online payments. These services charge you a fee for each transaction.

 

There are many handmade marketplaces that are free to sign up and create an account, but there’s typically some type of fee associated with selling through their platform, such as a listing fee (e.g. $0.20/listing) or a transaction fee (e.g. 3.5% of each transaction).

 

Other platforms may not charge listing or transaction fees but may charge a monthly membership fee. If they’re not charging you a transaction fee, you may be responsible for connecting your PayPal or Stripe account with your shop and those services will charge transaction fees directly to you.

 

If you set up a website for your craft business, you’ll have more costs to consider such as:

  • Purchasing a domain name and paying for it each year
  • Web hosting
  • Website builder (some are free, depending on the features your site needs)
  • Website design and development (even if you’re taking these tasks on yourself, you must still pay yourself for your time)

 

On top of that, you must connect your shop with a payment account (e.g. PayPal, Stripe, etc.) so your shoppers can complete transactions online. These services charge a transaction fee for each payment you receive.

 

You have a few options for listing and selling your handmade products for free but if you want to collect payments online, there will always be a fee.

 

 

THE PROS & CONS OF SELLING HANDMADE ONLINE

Selling online makes it relatively quick and easy for a business to get set up, start reaching consumers, and begin making sales. However, a lot of people underestimate how much work is required to sell online.

 

You, of course, must set your business up legally, just like any other business. Check out: LAWS FOR SELLING HANDMADE. You not only have to follow laws for the city your business is in but also the laws of the countries you’re shipping your products to.

 

CONS

 

Shipping

Shipping must be considered when selling online. Are your items easy to ship? How much will it cost to ship items within your city/province or state/country? Sometimes shipping fees can make a shopper reconsider if they really need an item. If the price to ship your products is higher than customers are willing to pay, you may need to work some of those fees into your product prices so shipping fees appear smaller.

 

Competition

You also must build a strong brand that attracts your target market. Consumers have endless options online and there’s more competition, so your business must quickly and clearly communicate what it does differently or better than its competitors. Your brand will help you get that message across.

 

Marketing

As you’ve probably heard, they do not come just because you build it. Getting shoppers to any online shop takes consistent work. Years ago, you could set up a shop on Etsy and easily get traffic to it and sales from it. Now, it’s much more competitive online. Because it is so easy to set up a shop, more businesses are doing it and you must work harder to get a piece of traffic and sales.

No matter which platform you use to sell online, you must work on SEO (search engine optimization) and use multiple marketing channels to get your products in front of people and drive them directly to your shop.

 

Algorithm Changes

As we’ve learned from Etsy (check out WHAT’S GOING ON WITH ETSY?), a platform can change their rules and functionality at any time, which can tank your sales. The same can happen with search engines such as Google. They’re constantly updating their rules for SEO best practices and an update can also tank traffic to your website overnight. And, we’re also aware of how social media channels such as Facebook, can make changes that limit how many of your followers you can reach with a post.

The safest way to protect yourself from these changes is to have an email list.

As long as you’re not doing anything to get your emails marked as spam, every one of your messages is guaranteed to land in your subscribers’ inboxes. Get your newsletter started today (here’s how) and focus on growing it so you have some padding when an algorithm change happens.

 

Product Features

It’s harder for product features to be communicated online. When people shop in person they’re able to pick an item up / try it on / feel it / touch it / see the quality / etc. You must put effort into your product photos and descriptions to ensure the important qualities come through to online shoppers and they have all the information they need to make a purchasing decision.

 

PROS

 

Quick Setup

You can get an online shop set up within a day. It will take time to grow traffic to your shop but if you have an advertising budget, you can expedite that process.

 

Large Audience

You can reach people across the world when you sell online.

 

Low Costs

Although there are costs to getting set up online, you can be strategic and keep those costs relatively low.

 

 

WHICH CRAFTS TO SELL ONLINE

The options are endless when it comes to products you can sell online. Here’s a list of 100+ CRAFTS TO MAKE & SELL FROM HOME (but these aren’t just any crafts…these are ideas that appeal to niches and are more likely to get consumers to pull their wallets out and buy from you.)

 

Other things to think about when it comes to the products you sell online are:

 

 

  • Shipping – items that are easy and cheap to ship are better suited for selling online

 

  • Shopping habits – consider what type of products consumers typically head online to buy. Most people don’t go online to buy lip balm; they grab that when they’re standing in line at the grocery store. If they’re trying to find a lip balm or lipstick that’s a specific, hard to find color, or uses ingredients that aren’t typically used in lip balms, then they might search for it online and buy from an online shop.

 

For more ideas on what to sell online, check out:

 

 

SHOULD YOU SELL ON MULTIPLE MARKETPLACES?

I don’t recommend joining as many online marketplaces as you can and listing your products.

 

It can raise your expenses each month, complicate stock management, and make it difficult to keep up with business tasks (check out THE SUCCESS PLANNER for a better idea of what those business tasks should be)

 

The ins and outs of a marketplace must be mastered to be a top seller on any platform, which takes time and effort.

 

Knowing how to create a listing, how often to post, which tags to use, which types of listings garner more attention and traffic, etc. requires a learning curve for each platform. Consider if you have time to master each for multiple platforms before setting up a shop on another marketplace.

 

The better approach, if you’re going to use more than one online marketplace, is to research the target market each hits, and spread your efforts between ones that reach a different customer.

 

For example, Etsy is used worldwide but over 50% of users are in the US. Amazon Handmade, Artfire, and Zibbet also have the majority of their users in the US.

So although you may reach a few different customers on Artfire than you would through Etsy, the people who shop on Artfire are probably aware of Etsy and likely to only shop both platforms when they can’t find what they’re looking for on one.

 

Instead, you may want to create a shop on an online marketplace that reaches shoppers in a different country or people who are looking for a specific item, such as art.

 

Make sure you have time to dedicate to each marketplace and can manage stock so you don’t sell one item on two sites.

 

Assess the ROI (return on investment) both money-wise (e.g. are you selling enough to cover your listing/membership fees each month) and time-wise (e.g. are you making enough sales each month to get paid for the hours you put into the platform?).

 

Learn more about ROI and other numbers that are essential for a handmade business owner to know in THE SUCCESS PLANNER.

 

 

HOW TO STAY ON ETSY & IMPROVE SALES

If you’re currently selling on Etsy and are considering leaving out of frustration, keep in mind that Etsy is the top-ranked site out of almost every website listed on this page.

 

Currently, it’s in the top 100 websites in the US (that’s out of ALL websites, not just online marketplaces) and top 200 globally. Websites such as Artfire, Zibbet, and Folksy don’t even come close to the top 100, 200 or even 1000.

 

This article shares ideas to diversify your online sales but I would encourage you not to abandon Etsy out of spite or frustration; weigh your options first and make a decision based on what’s best for your business.

 

Here’s how to determine if selling on Etsy is worth it for your craft business.

 

Etsy makes changes based on their business and what’s going to create a better shopping experience and encourage more sales.

 

So when Etsy changes their algorithm and it results in fewer sales for you, you have every right to feel annoyed, but get over it quickly and head back to the drawing board to figure out how you can get your listings back into searches.

 

Check out this article for some ideas to improve your Etsy shop based on their latest algorithm changes.

 

Be sure to take your time to research each online sales channel before you dive in. Understand the costs, the platform’s audience, steps to list, etc. so you’re well aware of the money and time investment and are certain you’ll reach the right people to make sales.

 

 

LINKS MENTIONED IN THE ARTICLE

 

Have you tried any of the online marketplaces mentioned in this article? Share your opinions on them in the comments!

 



Finally understand why your hard work isn't resulting in more sales

Join over 18,000 others and sign up for the
Made Urban newsletter


Powered by ConvertKit
Previous Post
Next Post